Home / FAQs / How to save thousands with Members 1st Federal Credit Union

How to save thousands with Members 1st Federal Credit Union

Although you are a member of Members 1st Federal Credit Union there is a 76% chance that you have your car loan with another lender. You probably got your loan at the dealership when you bought the car, which isn't ideal because Members 1st Federal Credit Union offers you much lower rates. In fact, you can probably save more than $300 every year / $25 every month through refinancing.

The good news is that we can help fix this quickly, especially if you made all of your loan payments on time. Instead of making your monthly payment to the other lender, check your eligibility and refinance now.

Table of contents


  1. How to make your Members 1st Federal Credit Union payment
  2. Some background on Members 1st Federal Credit Union
  3. Refinance your auto loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union
  4. Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan payoff amount
  5. How soon can you refinance your loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union
  6. Will refinancing your loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union hurt your credit
  7. Can I skip a car payment with Members 1st Federal Credit Union
  8. Does Members 1st Federal Credit Union have a grace period
  9. How long does Members 1st Federal Credit Union take to repossess my car
  10. What happens if I pay extra on my Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan
  11. Savings from refinancing with Members 1st Federal Credit Union
  12. Members 1st Federal Credit Union reviews
  13. Does Members 1st Federal Credit Union report to the credit bureaus
  14. Members 1st Federal Credit Union car loan refinance rates
  15. Can you refinance your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan with the same lender
  16. Refinance your loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union now

How to make your Members 1st Federal Credit Union payment


If you currently have a loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union paying online is easy. Simply go to https://www.members1st.org/ and mid right at Sign In. You can choose between:

  • Making a one time payment.
  • Enrolling in Autopay from your checking account.

Please note that many banks and financial institutions offer a discount for enrolling in autopay (to reduce your interest expense and lower your monthly payment). Members 1st Federal Credit Union would have highlighted this option to you to get you into a lower interest rate when you got pre-qualified for your auto financing.

If you can't pay online, you've also got the option to:

Pay your bill over the phone: Call 1-800-237-7288

Pay your bill through the mail: Send a check to Members 1st Federal Credit Union

Members 1st Federal Credit Union
Loan Servicing Department
5000 Louise Drive
P. O. Box 40
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055

Nicholas Hinrichsen - Published: September 5, 2020

Some background on Members 1st Federal Credit Union


Before going into more detail, here a little background about Members 1st Federal Credit Union: Members 1st Federal Credit Union was founded in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, in 1950. The company is still in Mechanicsburg, and is currently run by CEO is George Nahodil. There are over 360,000 members and $3.5 billion in assets at Members 1st FCU. Members First is insured by the NCUA, meaning that members indivdual accounts are insured up to $250,000 by the US Government.

The company believes in giving back and employees put in thousands of volunteer hours each year, on top of the monetary donations Members First gives. If you are interested in talking to a service representative, check the business hours to find a time that works for both of you!

Members 1st Federal Credit Union has a seasoned management team with financial services expertise, leading a team of 1,051 full time employees. Like most federal credit unions, which are non-profit organizations, Members 1st Federal Credit Union is a different kind of financial institutions. Headquartered in Mechanicsburg (PA), George Nahodil is responsible as the CEO of the financial cooperative supported by Eric Bush as the CFO and Kathy Jumper as the COO.

Members 1st Federal Credit Union is Federally Chartered and Insured and offers - next to bank accounts with lower fees, checking accounts, access to a number of ATMs, FDIC approved savings accounts with high savings rates, money market accounts with high saving rates, student loans, debit cards, credit cards and other superior products - two important loan offerings with better rates. Mortgages (incl. home loans and HELOCs) and auto loans, including for first time buyers:

Mortgages (incl. home loans and HELOCs):
Financial health, financial well-being, financial education and members' financial quality are Members 1st Federal Credit Union's main objectives. Members 1st Federal Credit Union therefore offers mortgages, home loans and a home equity line of credit at low rates and through an online mortgage application.

Mortgage rates are currently at the rock bottom, which is great for homeowners. A lot of Members 1st Federal Credit Union's members are taking advantage of the low rates and refinance.

Auto loans
24% of the members have auto loans with Members 1st Federal Credit Union while the other 76% of the members either don't have auto loans at all or got their vehicle-loans at the dealership, during the car sale process and are overpaying. If you were to get your auto loan from the nonprofit today while interest rates are at the rock bottom, your APR for excellent credit on a new car would be 3.6% and on a used car would be 3.9%.

In total, Members 1st Federal Credit Union has given 105,674 auto loans to its members worth $1,356M. Out of these loans, 67% are for used cars and 33% for new cars. Members 1st Federal Credit Union gets 43% of its auto loans through partnerships with dealerships and 57% through its business services, call centers and service centers which have a direct relationship with the members.

Once you become a credit union member, you benefit from all of Members 1st Federal Credit Union's financial products and banking services. Historically, you'd visit the physical branches and build a relationship with the branch manager and tellers. If you are a small business owner, you probably regularly visited the branch during teller hours to check your account balances. Today, in contrast, most of your interactions with Members 1st Federal Credit Union are through mobile banking via the mobile app. Even your chamber of commerce transitioned to an online experience!

Members 1st Federal Credit Union targets the segment of American car shoppers with great (i.e. super prime) credit and we observed an average auto loan interest rate of 5% (within a range of +/- 1%), while rates vary a lot by credit score. Our Members 1st Federal Credit Union auto loan calculator can pre-qualify you through a simple credit application and help you get a sense for how much you can expect to save from a Members 1st Federal Credit Union auto refinance and the best rates.

Refinance your auto loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union


Even if you already have your loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union, you might be able to lower your monthly payments. We need to find you a lender that can extend your used car loan term or who offers lower auto loan rates before the loan is paid in full. Usually, lenders offer you a lower rate than your current auto loan for one of two reasons:

  1. When you bought your car, the participating dealer received a referral fee from Members 1st Federal Credit Union, which ultimately came out of your pocket. That's common for auto loan originations and to make more money.
  2. You improved your credit over time and now qualify for a lower car payment and interest rate.

Both of these observations are the reason for why you can save a lot of money, especially if you use your car for personal use. You had great credit with the credit bureaus and further improved your credit report, you're not facing any financial difficulties and therefore, your new lender will be likely one of the following ones:


You already had super prime credit segment (FICO above 720 on your credit history) and are wondering if you can still save some money or stretch your loan? Credit Unions love super-prime members. These lenders have a community charter, are FDIC approved and are non-profits providing a great customer experience. Therefore, the rates are as low as they get.

In the following, we will walk you through the exact steps to pay off your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan. If you want to skip the details and refinance now through a simple loan application, get an offer with a few clicks and with no impact on your credit.

Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan payoff amount


First and foremost, we need to pull up your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan payoff statement. The loan payoff statement is not your outstanding balance. Instead, the loan payoff statement summarizes the following data points:

  • your payoff amount (usually your loan amount balance plus a few small fees)
  • the due date until your payoff is valid to avoid late fees (usually 10 days from when you requested it)
  • the per-diem (how much of daily interest your loan accumulates)
  • your account number (the new lender needs that to payoff your loan)
  • the payoff address (the new lender needs to know where to mail the check to)

There is no such thing as prepayment penalty and all the above information can be found on the official payoff statement and just to be clear. You have multiple payment options but first you need to locate the payoff statement from Members 1st Federal Credit Union's customer service reps:

  1. Call the Members 1st Federal Credit Union customer service phone number at 1-800-237-7288 and ask to be connected to the loan payoff department.
  2. Log into the online banking at Sign In (https://www.members1st.org/, mid right) and browse to the 'Loan Payoff' tab. You will be able to download a PDF.
  3. Do a three-way phone call with the new lender and a Members 1st Federal Credit Union customer service rep at 1-800-237-7288, which allows the new lender to ask Members 1st Federal Credit Union all the questions necessary to pay off your existing loan.

Should you plan to payoff your loan and you are currently in the United States, you can overnight a check to the following address:

Members 1st Federal Credit Union
Loan Servicing Department
5000 Louise Drive
P. O. Box 40
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055

Once you paid off your auto loan, expect to receive the vehicle title along with a lien release letter in the mail. Car loans are usually secured personal loans and in order to be able to sell your vehicle or refinance it, you need the lien release in hand.

We provided those addresses above because we always struggle to find a service provider's contact information. Just be aware, due to COVID-19, waiting times for customer service reps might be longer than usual. Want us to take care of the refinance for you? We can lower your rate in less than two minutes.

How soon can you refinance your loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union


You're eager to refinance your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan? Great, you should absolutely work towards lowering your Members 1st Federal Credit Union payments through refinancing.

Dealers make most of their money on finance and insurance products. Therefore, there's a good chance that you are overpaying and can save money through refinancing - already the day you drive off the lot! That said, you will save the biggest amount of money from refinancing after you made 12 to 18 payments. That's when you will notice the effect from improving your credit above and beyond great (i.e. super prime) credit.

That said, we recommend checking regularly: you can get a free refinance offer with no impact on your credit in three simple steps.

Will refinancing your loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union hurt your credit


Refinancing will not hurt your credit! If you have the app CreditKarma installed on your phone, take a peek at what factors determine your credit. You will find the following:

  • Number of Hard Inquiries (less is better)
  • Age of Credit history (more is better)
  • Credit Card Utilization (less is better)
  • Total Accounts (more is better)
  • Derogatory Marks (less is better)
  • Payment History (more is better)

None of these factors is impacted negatively if you obtain a refinancing offer for your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan. Lenders don't need to do a hard credit inquiry to make you a firm refinance offer. Neither do they charge an application fee. From a soft credit pull, we can see your whole credit file and estimate your rate.

Should you decide to accept the refinance offer, the new lender will have to perform a hard inquiry in order to add your new loan to your credit file. The hard inquiry, however, only happens after you have been approved.

We argue that the positive impact of refinancing your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan outweigh the negative impact of the hard credit inquiry: after you refinance your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan, you will have a lower rate and lower monthly payments. As a result, the likelihood that you will be able to establish a perfect payment history increases which will drive your score up quickly.

Can I skip a car payment with Members 1st Federal Credit Union


You're short on cash and are wondering whether you can skip a car payment with Members 1st Federal Credit Union? The answer is yes, you can defer one or more payments on your existing auto loan. You have to talk to Members 1st Federal Credit Union about the deferral first though. You can't just not pay or you risk collection calls and ultimately a repossession.

Ideally, you give Members 1st Federal Credit Union a call at 1-800-237-7288 and describe your situation. Members 1st Federal Credit Union's goal is for you to make your payments throughout the whole term of the loan. Finance charges will continue to accrue on the unpaid loan balance, which means you will end up paying more on your loan after all. But for as long as you communicate well with Members 1st Federal Credit Union, they will defer one or more payments out of courtesy and to help you with your repayment.

All that said, you can lower your Members 1st Federal Credit Union payments through refinancing if you've made all your latest payments on time. In three simple steps, you can find out how low your payments could be without having to skip a payment or two.

Does Members 1st Federal Credit Union have a grace period


The Members 1st Federal Credit Union late payment policy provides a grace period of 7 to 15 days. Grace periods vary from lender to lender and due to the coronavirus pandemic, banks have become a lot more lenient with their borrowers.

Late fees vary drastically by loan, the minimum late fee we've encountered was 5% of the monthly payment amount. However, we strongly advise not to take advantage of Members 1st Federal Credit Union's grace period unless you have an emergency. You'd be putting your credit at risk, which can have a long-term, negative impact on your personal finances.

Instead, we recommend exploring if refinancing can help you reduce your monthly burden and potentially even provide unexpected cost savings. Provide your phone number and follow our three simple steps to get a firm offer, 100% online and with no hit on your credit.

How long does Members 1st Federal Credit Union take to repossess my car


Repossession law varies slightly from state to state and range from 3 to 5 months after you stopped making payments on your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan. Each individual retail and installment contract - the contract you signed when you got your car and Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan - states what constitutes a default.

Some states and contracts even trigger a repossession within 45 days (or a month and a half) of being in default. You are in default when you stopped making your payments and for as long as you haven't paid the Members 1st Federal Credit Union late fees.

Just catching up with your missed payments making Members 1st Federal Credit Union whole doesn't automatically mean you're not in default anymore. You really need to pay Members 1st Federal Credit Union everything you owe including fees to be not considered in default any longer.

What happens if I pay extra on my Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan


The answer is simple: your loan term will shorten but your monthly payment will stay the same. A number of our customers hope they can reduce their monthly payments through paying extra but no lender will do that.

To lower your monthly payments, you have to refinance your loan. If you haven't considered refinancing your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan yet, you definitely should: not only can you reduce your monthly payments within 2 minutes or less, your total interest expense will go down as well and as a result, you can save $150 every year / $13 every month.

Savings from refinancing with Members 1st Federal Credit Union


We performed a study on the top 40 auto loan companies to refinance and found that the average Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan rate is around 5% (within a range of +/- 1%). If you made your payments for 6 / 12 / 18 consecutive months, you're guaranteed to be able to save money on your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan.

Your new interest rate should be on the order of 4% or below. That means you will save $100 every year / $8 every month if your remaining loan balance is around $10,000 and you refinance. Usually, we see higher loan balances when refinancing our customers, e.g. around $15,000. If your loan balance is around $15,000 you will save $150 every year / $13 every month when you lower your rate by 1%.

For a guaranteed rate in less than 2 minutes, open WithClutch.com, enter your phone number, select your goal (e.g. 'Lower my monthly payment') and click on 'Apply Now'. Our process will not hurt your credit and you'll receive a firm and guaranteed rate with not more than 5 clicks. Should you have any further questions, check out our FAQs.

Members 1st Federal Credit Union reviews


If you currently have a loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union, you most likely got the loan at the dealership during the car purchase. You probably used your used vehicle as a trade-in to lower your down payment. The dealer found you your loan and you can make your payments by clicking on Sign In at https://www.members1st.org/.

79% of all Americans with auto loans get their auto loan at the dealership. People shop for new cars, they don't shop for new loans. As a result, auto dealers have a leg up when it comes to giving car shoppers loans. In fact, the same is true for auto insurance and when you inquire about a warranty.

The challenge is this:

  1. the number 1 goal of a car dealer is to sell a car
  2. the number 2 goal of a car dealer is to sell the car at the highest possible margin

Considering the interests of the car dealer and how most car shoppers get their loans, no wonder Americans are overpaying on their interest rates, right?

As mentioned above, Members 1st Federal Credit Union is an auto loan and financial services company that specializes on the segment of Americans with great (i.e. super prime) credit. We looked at reviews for Members 1st Federal Credit Union and found the following:

  • BBB: 1 out of 5 stars from 25 complaints
  • Wallethub: 3 out of 5 stars from 39 reviews
  • Glassdoor: 3.8 out of 5 stars from 57 reviews

Ever wondered if Members 1st Federal Credit Union treats everyone like you? Sadly, they do. Other loans you might have also qualified for could have been with one of the following auto loan companies:


If you bought your car at a Franchise Dealership, you may have qualified for a loan with one of the Captive Finance companies (i.e. the auto loan companies that are owned by the respective car brand), e.g.:


After you've made your first 6 / 12 / 18 payments, your chance to refinance your loan and lower your monthly payments has come. The challenge with refinancing is that most auto loan companies require you to visit their branch before they can give you any indication of how much money you will be saving. Fortunately, we can help with that.

Does Members 1st Federal Credit Union report to the credit bureaus


When you first obtained your auto loan, Members 1st Federal Credit Union reported your new loan to the credit bureaus. Your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan shows up as a so called trade-line on your credit report. Through a soft or hard credit inquiry, we can see:

  • When you got your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan
  • What your initial balance was
  • How high your monthly payment is
  • Whether you've made your payments in time and full
  • How high your outstanding balance is
  • How many payments are remaining

If you miss a payment, Members 1st Federal Credit Union will very likely report the incident to the credit bureaus. Just like any other auto finance company, Members 1st Federal Credit Union will also report to the credit bureaus when you paid off your loan or refinanced it. In both of those cases, your loan will show up as paid off.

Members 1st Federal Credit Union car loan refinance rates


We can help you get the following Members 1st Federal Credit Union refinance rates:

Credit New car Used car
760+ 2.69% 3.49%
700-760 3.00% 4.25%
650-700 5.50% 6.50%
600-650 9.75% 10.75%
550-600 15.50% 17.50%
Below 550 22.00% 22.00%

As mentioned above, Members 1st Federal Credit Union car loan rates vary a lot by credit score, i.e. lowest rate for excellent credit to highest rate for challenged credit. Yet, the rates are usually the same no matter where you live in the United States - be it Hawaii or Maine, Alaska or Florida. We therefore recommend taking a look at your Members 1st Federal Credit Union refinance offer for your exact and personalized refinance terms.

Can you refinance your Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan with the same lender


The answer is short and sweat: no, you cannot refinance a Members 1st Federal Credit Union loan with the same lender. Members 1st Federal Credit Union does one of two things with your loan:

  • Keep it and generate profit over the course of the loan and while you are paying your interest.
  • Sell your loan to an institutional investor or the public through a securitization to realize a lump sum profit immediately.

In both of those cases, the institution holding your loan is expecting your monthly payments. When you refinance, however, you change the expected cash flow to Members 1st Federal Credit Union, which impacts Members 1st Federal Credit Union's bottom line. Members 1st Federal Credit Union would not allow that.

Therefore, Members 1st Federal Credit Union won't let you refinance your loan with the same lender (i.e. Members 1st Federal Credit Union). Instead, you need to find a new lender offering a lower rate.

Fortunately, we recently studied the best auto loan refinancing companies and wrote a thorough review. In a nutshell, only WithClutch offers a fully digital pre-qualification experience, even for borrowers with minimum monthly income and without charging unreasonable fees. We do our best to give our clients the best auto refinance loans. Our partner lenders can offer the lowest rates and can help with lease buyouts as well as refinancing.

Refinance your loan with Members 1st Federal Credit Union now



Haven't explored refinancing yet?
WithClutch.com is a fully digital platform that lets car owners like you do so from the comfort of their own home. No need to set a foot in a bank or credit union. You can lower your rate or get cash in as little as 20 seconds.

Follow three simple steps to refinance your auto loan, get approved in seconds and save thousands in minutes.

Consumer Solutions

Commercial Solutions

Developer Tools

Address

WithClutch, LLC

2120 E El Parque Dr

Tempe, AZ 85282

Contact

Legal

© 2020 WithClutch. All rights reserved.